How the community keeps the site trustworthy
One rule sits above the rest: an entry anchored to a specific room number and one real guest photo. Everything else follows from that.
This page is a working draft. The principles below restate rules from the approved Knowledge document, but the specific wording here was newly written during the Stage 3 redesign. Staging-only and search-engine-blocked until Aki approves the final text.
The one non-negotiable
Every contribution is anchored to a specific room (number or, where the hotel has none, an exact category name) and a photograph taken from that room. No photo, no entry. "Nice hotel, great views" is on every other site — that isn't what we're building.
Yes, please
- Room-level specificity. "Room 3515, floor 3, end of wing" is exactly the entry we want. So is a wing/floor line ("rooms ending 14/15 on floors 2–3 get the chapel view too").
- Your own photograph. Taken by you, or someone who has given you permission to share. Cropping and brightness are fine; edits that change what the camera saw are not.
- Honest drawbacks. If the room has noise, an obstruction, a season-dependent quirk — say so. That's the most useful part of the entry.
- Practical request wording. The exact phrase you'd use if you were emailing the hotel to ask. Real request wording is the single most valuable thing you can share.
No, thank you
- Marketing photos from the hotel website, on a room page. If it isn't your own view, it doesn't belong there. (Guide pages are different — see below.)
- Reviews of the hotel in general. There are dozens of sites for that; this one is for the room.
- Fake or exaggerated claims. Small community, tight quality bar — one bad entry does more damage than ten missing ones.
- Content that could identify staff or other guests. Views out of the window only, never into another room.
Two kinds of photograph, two different rules
It is worth being precise about this, because the rules deliberately differ and the difference is the whole point.
- Room pages carry evidence. A room page exists to show you what one specific room actually looks out on. The only acceptable photograph is one a guest took from that room. No hotel imagery, no stock, no exceptions. This rule is absolute and will not change.
- Guide pages carry context. A guide is our own compiled research about a hotel — which wings face what, which categories are sold on the view. Here we use photographs of the hotel itself: openly-licensed images where they exist, and images from the hotel's own press or media kit, which are published expressly for editorial use. Every one is labelled for what it is and credited to its source.
So: a hotel press photograph may appear on a guide page, clearly marked as such. It will never appear on a room page, and it is never presented as a guest photograph. If you ever see an image on this site that is unclear about which it is, that is a mistake and we want to hear about it.
Verified vs Compiled — the labels you'll see
- Compiled guide. Assembled from publicly available traveller reports and hotel information. No verified guest stay yet. The hero image is a labelled context image, never a fake guest photograph.
- Partially verified. One or more real guest contributions exist. Verified rooms appear as their own cards with real photos, notes and request wording.
- Community verified. The strongest state — multiple independent contributors have confirmed a consistent view pattern. A separate "community consensus" summary appears above the individual rooms.
Every label reflects real data. The state upgrades automatically as contributions accumulate; nothing is ever hand-set to look busier than it is.
Reporting a problem
Every page has a "Report a correction" link at the bottom. If a room has changed, if a photo isn't right, or if a claim doesn't match your own stay — tell us. We act promptly and confirm when it's done.